Contact Us

Homes for Sale in Sheffield Lake, OH

19 listings · Updated daily from the MLS · October 2026

Sheffield Lake is a smaller Lorain County city on the Lake Erie shoreline, just west of Avon Lake. It tends to offer some of the more attainable lake-area price points on the West Shore, with a mix of lakefront and near-lake homes.

19Active listings
$259,900Median list price
84Avg. days on market
$140,000 – $649,000Price range
4502 Edgewater Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$625,000
81 days on market
4502 Edgewater Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 3 BA Square Feet 2,202 sq ft
MLS ID #5232224, RE/MAX Crossroads Properties, Anthony R Latina, Listing Provided by MLS Now
870 Community Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$299,000
109 days on market
870 Community Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,518 sq ft
MLS ID #5225957, Russell Real Estate Services, Steven Lawson, Listing Provided by MLS Now
5394 Hawks Nest Circle, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$415,000
126 days on market
5394 Hawks Nest Circle, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 4 BA Square Feet 3,312 sq ft
MLS ID #5220375, Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty, Christopher A Frederick, Listing Provided by MLS Now
4641 E Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$229,900
133 days on market
4641 E Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,068 sq ft
MLS ID #5218984, Regal Realty, Inc., Roger H Peters, Listing Provided by MLS Now
666 Treadway Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$270,000
156 days on market
666 Treadway Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,685 sq ft
MLS ID #5212729, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Professional Realty, Kim Kelly, Listing Provided by MLS Now
620 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$224,900
178 days on market
620 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,400 sq ft
MLS ID #5206232, BlueRoots Real Estate Group, Duane A Linder, Listing Provided by MLS Now
605 W Shore Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$199,900
309 days on market
605 W Shore Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 2 BR Bathrooms 1 BA
MLS ID #5176756, Russell Real Estate Services, Chris Kilbane, Listing Provided by MLS Now

Get pre-qualified with Broker Broker Mortgage

Your Sheffield Lake Realtor is also a mortgage broker. Get pre-qualified first, shop with a clear budget, and keep the whole process with one local team.

Get pre-qualified

Broker Broker Realty and Broker Broker Mortgage are affiliated businesses and use of each is optional. Broker Broker Mortgage LLC, NMLS #2532922. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sheffield Lake real estate FAQ

How many homes are for sale in Sheffield Lake, OH?

There are currently 19 active listings in Sheffield Lake, OH, ranging from $140,000 to $649,000, with a median list price of $259,900. Listings on this page update daily from the MLS.

What ZIP code is Sheffield Lake, Ohio?

Sheffield Lake is in Lorain County, Ohio, ZIP code 44054.

Can I get pre-qualified and buy a home in Sheffield Lake with the same team?

Yes. Dalton Summers is both a licensed real estate broker with Broker Broker Realty and a mortgage broker with Broker Broker Mortgage (NMLS #2532922). The two companies are affiliated, and using each is optional.

How do I schedule a showing in Sheffield Lake?

Open any listing and tap Request a Showing, or call 440-420-9724.

What nearby areas can I search?

Homebuyers searching Sheffield Lake often also look at Avon Lake, Sheffield Village.

Nearby cities