Contact Us

Homes for Sale in Sheffield Lake, OH

19 listings · Updated daily from the MLS · October 2026

Sheffield Lake is a smaller Lorain County city on the Lake Erie shoreline, just west of Avon Lake. It tends to offer some of the more attainable lake-area price points on the West Shore, with a mix of lakefront and near-lake homes.

19Active listings
$259,900Median list price
84Avg. days on market
$140,000 – $649,000Price range
559 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$159,000
3 days on market
559 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR
MLS ID #5255604, Keller Williams Citywide, Breanna Johnson, Listing Provided by MLS Now
916 West Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$259,900
9 days on market
916 West Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,996 sq ft
MLS ID #5254073, HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC, Krista A Viola, Listing Provided by MLS Now
992 Lakewood Beach Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$325,000
31 days on market
992 Lakewood Beach Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 5 BR Bathrooms 2 BA
MLS ID #5247911, Keller Williams Greater Metropolitan, Sabrina Mitchell, Listing Provided by MLS Now
652 Alameda Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$260,000
43 days on market
652 Alameda Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 4 BR Bathrooms 3 BA Square Feet 2,398 sq ft
MLS ID #5244560, JMG Ohio, Amy Zientarski, Listing Provided by MLS Now
911 West Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$249,900
44 days on market
911 West Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA
MLS ID #5241981, Civitas Real Estate Group, Jonathan Wright, Listing Provided by MLS Now
4532 Edgewater Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$649,000
45 days on market
4532 Edgewater Drive, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,376 sq ft
MLS ID #5244474, RE/MAX Real Estate Group, Dante DiBenedetto, Listing Provided by MLS Now
531 Robinwood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$140,000
46 days on market
531 Robinwood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 2 BR Bathrooms 1 BA Square Feet 1,247 sq ft
MLS ID #5244066, Market First Real Estate Services, Steven L DeWitt, Listing Provided by MLS Now
618 Idlewood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$199,000
53 days on market
618 Idlewood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA
MLS ID #5242652, Russell Real Estate Services, Carol Gallardo, Listing Provided by MLS Now
874 Idlewood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$349,900
55 days on market
874 Idlewood Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 3 BA
MLS ID #5241395, HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC, Lana K Stover, Listing Provided by MLS Now
839 Sheffield Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$285,000
58 days on market
839 Sheffield Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 1 BA Square Feet 1,120 sq ft
MLS ID #5239229, Keller Williams Chervenic Rlty, Christine Dessoffy, Listing Provided by MLS Now
4651 E Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$244,900
60 days on market
4651 E Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 3 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 2,301 sq ft
MLS ID #5238735, RE/MAX Crossroads Properties, Joe Dirk, Listing Provided by MLS Now
782 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
$245,000
61 days on market
782 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054
Bedrooms 4 BR Bathrooms 2 BA Square Feet 1,564 sq ft
MLS ID #5239728, Keller Williams Citywide, Thomas Kelly, Listing Provided by MLS Now

About Sheffield Lake, Ohio

Because inventory is limited, new listings can move quickly — which is why we recommend setting up a search alert and getting pre-qualified before you start touring. Sheffield Lake is in the Sheffield-Sheffield Lake City School District.

  • Lake Erie frontage in a small city
  • More attainable lake-area price points
  • Limited inventory — pre-approval helps
  • Sheffield-Sheffield Lake City School District

Buying a home in Sheffield Lake

Broker Broker Realty is a local brokerage led by Dalton “Red” Summers. We track new Sheffield Lake listings every day, help you compare neighborhoods and price points, and walk you through offers, inspections and closing. Because Dalton is also a mortgage broker (Broker Broker Mortgage, NMLS #2532922), you can get pre-qualified and know your budget before you tour — using both services is optional.

Selling a home in Sheffield Lake

Thinking about selling? We start with a data-based pricing analysis of comparable Sheffield Lake sales and current competition, then handle professional marketing and negotiation. Call 440-420-9724 for a free consultation.

Get pre-qualified with Broker Broker Mortgage

Your Sheffield Lake Realtor is also a mortgage broker. Get pre-qualified first, shop with a clear budget, and keep the whole process with one local team.

Get pre-qualified

Broker Broker Realty and Broker Broker Mortgage are affiliated businesses and use of each is optional. Broker Broker Mortgage LLC, NMLS #2532922. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sheffield Lake real estate FAQ

How many homes are for sale in Sheffield Lake, OH?

There are currently 19 active listings in Sheffield Lake, OH, ranging from $140,000 to $649,000, with a median list price of $259,900. Listings on this page update daily from the MLS.

What ZIP code is Sheffield Lake, Ohio?

Sheffield Lake is in Lorain County, Ohio, ZIP code 44054.

Can I get pre-qualified and buy a home in Sheffield Lake with the same team?

Yes. Dalton Summers is both a licensed real estate broker with Broker Broker Realty and a mortgage broker with Broker Broker Mortgage (NMLS #2532922). The two companies are affiliated, and using each is optional.

How do I schedule a showing in Sheffield Lake?

Open any listing and tap Request a Showing, or call 440-420-9724.

What nearby areas can I search?

Homebuyers searching Sheffield Lake often also look at Avon Lake, Sheffield Village.

Nearby cities