Homes for Sale in Sheffield Lake Under $500,000

17 listings · Updated daily from the MLS · October 2026

Browse 17 homes under $500,000 currently for sale in Sheffield Lake, Ohio (Lorain County, ZIP 44054). Each listing below links to full photos, price, size and MLS details. Want one of them toured or need help narrowing the list? Call 440-420-9724.

19Active listings

$259,900Median list price

84Avg. days on market

$140,000 – $649,000Price range

$415,000

126 days on market

5394 Hawks Nest Circle, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

3 BR

4 BA

3,312 sq ft

MLS ID #5220375, Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty, Christopher A Frederick, Listing Provided by MLS Now

$229,900

133 days on market

4641 E Lake Road, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

3 BR

2 BA

1,068 sq ft

MLS ID #5218984, Regal Realty, Inc., Roger H Peters, Listing Provided by MLS Now

$270,000

156 days on market

666 Treadway Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

3 BR

2 BA

1,685 sq ft

MLS ID #5212729, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Professional Realty, Kim Kelly, Listing Provided by MLS Now

$224,900

178 days on market

620 Pasadena Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

3 BR

2 BA

1,400 sq ft

MLS ID #5206232, BlueRoots Real Estate Group, Duane A Linder, Listing Provided by MLS Now

$199,900

309 days on market

605 W Shore Boulevard, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

2 BR

1 BA

MLS ID #5176756, Russell Real Estate Services, Chris Kilbane, Listing Provided by MLS Now

Get pre-qualified with Broker Broker Mortgage

Your Sheffield Lake Realtor is also a mortgage broker. Get pre-qualified first, shop with a clear budget, and keep the whole process with one local team.

Get pre-qualified

Broker Broker Realty and Broker Broker Mortgage are affiliated businesses and use of each is optional. Broker Broker Mortgage LLC, NMLS #2532922. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sheffield Lake real estate FAQ

How many homes are for sale in Sheffield Lake, OH?

There are currently 19 active listings in Sheffield Lake, OH, ranging from $140,000 to $649,000, with a median list price of $259,900. Listings on this page update daily from the MLS.

What ZIP code is Sheffield Lake, Ohio?

Sheffield Lake is in Lorain County, Ohio, ZIP code 44054.

Can I get pre-qualified and buy a home in Sheffield Lake with the same team?

Yes. Dalton Summers is both a licensed real estate broker with Broker Broker Realty and a mortgage broker with Broker Broker Mortgage (NMLS #2532922). The two companies are affiliated, and using each is optional.

How do I schedule a showing in Sheffield Lake?

Open any listing and tap Request a Showing, or call 440-420-9724.

What nearby areas can I search?

Homebuyers searching Sheffield Lake often also look at Avon Lake, Sheffield Village.

Register to see all properties

Get pre-qualified with Broker Broker Mortgage

Sheffield Lake real estate FAQ

Nearby cities